Honoré Daumier - Le meilleur des rois continuant a faire regner l'ordre dans ses etats (The best of kings continuing to keep order in his states), 1851

Honoré Daumier – Le meilleur des rois continuant a faire regner l’ordre dans ses etats (The best of kings continuing to keep order in his states), 1851

Political speech is the core expressive activity that forms the foundation of our democracy; it receives the highest level of protection under the First Amendment.  This protection includes art used in a political context, which covers everything from protest art to logos commissioned by political campaigns.  It also protects art that contains political aspects but has no clear political message, such as art that lampoons a public figure for the way they dress (which might also be considered parody).

In general, the First Amendment protects art with a political aspect unless it is found to be obscene or defamatory.  Additionally, political art that can be characterized as “extremist” because of its violent message or support for a group that advocates violence may be subject to restrictions on hate speech or true threats.  Finally, even where “extremist” statements in art cannot be prohibited or punished, artists should be aware that such expressions and associations with known “extremist” groups may subject them and their online activity to law enforcement surveillance without violating the First Amendment.  An artist might still run into some issues with political  if they seek to profit from using a political figure’s image, or if their speech is of a type regulated by campaign finance laws.  We discuss political figures’ privacy and publicity rights in our section on depictions of real people, and devote this section to campaign finance law.

Campaign finance laws govern the money that politicians spend to advertise and support their candidacy.  Campaign finance laws and freedom of expression can collide when regulations of campaign contributions limit the ability of a party to express their beliefs.  In some cases, artists may need to be aware of how those restrictions impact the use of their art, especially if the art is created in support of a specific candidate.

This area of law is generally not an issue for artists since campaign finance laws are focused on accounting for the money spent on a campaign, and not what private citizens say about the campaign.  But, if you create art that is related to a specific candidate or campaign, you should be aware of the ways that campaign finance law may restrict what you say and how you say it.  Federal laws govern federal elections while state laws govern state elections, and there may be some discrepancy between the two sets of laws as to what is allowed.

The Basics

Federal campaign finance law exempts many Internet-based political activities under an “uncompensated Internet activity” exemption from reporting requirements.  This exemption covers activities including, but not limited to, “sending or forwarding electronic messages; providing a hyperlink or other direct access to another person's Web site; blogging; creating, maintaining, or hosting a Web site; paying a nominal fee for the use of another person's Web site; and any other form of communication distributed over the Internet.”  Most political activity that artists engage in online will likely be covered by this exception.

One instance when an artist might need to examine campaign finance law more closely is when he or she has created art that is used in a political advertisement.  Essentially, the key question is whether the advertisement advocates for an issue or promotes the election or defeat of a specific candidate.  The first part of an inquiry by the Federal Election Commission is to see whether the advertisement clearly identifies a candidate.  According to the FEC, a “clearly identified candidate” is one whose “name, nickname, photograph, or drawing appears, or whose identity is apparent through unambiguous reference, such as ‘your Congressman,’ or through an unambiguous reference to his or her status as a candidate, such as ‘the Democratic presidential nominee’ or ‘Republican candidate for Senate in this state.’”

The second question, and the one that’s most important to an artist, is whether the art is intended for “public communication,” a term that has a special meaning in the Internet context.  Generally, a public communication is the broadcast of a message with the intent to reach a large audience.  Art (and its associated costs) that is created in support of such a communication must be reported as a campaign contribution to the FEC.  Fortunately, art posted only on the Internet is not considered a public communication unless it is placed on another person’s website for a fee – that is, if the artist pays another website to post his art as an advertisement.  Artists who create art about a political campaign and post it on their own website or blog, or on a free art- or photo-sharing website, should generally find that their art falls under the “uncompensated Internet activity” exemption.

What You Need to Know

Artists are free to post art on their own website, or free art-sharing sites, that supports the election or defeat of a candidate without any obligation to report the costs.

On the other hand, if you create art that calls for the election or defeat of a specific candidate and also pay to have your art posted on a third party’s website (most commonly in the form of an advertisement), federal election law requires clear disclaimers that include your name and address.  The same disclaimers must also be included if the art is posted as a paid advertisement to solicit contributions for a candidate.

Any money spent on Internet advertisements that supports election or defeat of a candidate is considered a campaign contribution – no matter how low the cost. 

If the amount spent is over $250, it must be reported to the Federal Election Commission.  So, if you create a design that clearly supports the election of a candidate and pay to post that art on a website for an event, that money is a considered a contribution, and may need to be reported.

Laws, Cases, and Other Resources

Buckley v. Valeo, 424 U.S. 1 (1976)

In 1971, Congress passed the Federal Election Campaign Act to regulate contributions to elections to federal office.  Two Senators filed suit, claiming the Act was unconstitutional.  The Supreme Court held that campaign finance regulations are not allowed to restrict freedom of speech.  Thus, the law could impose limits on the contributions made by individuals to a particular campaign, but expenditures by individuals or groups that merely express support of a candidate could not be limited in the same way. 

Wisconsin Right to Life v. Federal Election Commission, 551 U.S. 449 (2007)

The Wisconsin Right to Life (WRL), a nonprofit political action committee, sponsored advertisements urging voters to contact two senators to filibuster judicial nominees. The McCain-Feingold Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act of 2002 (BCRA) prohibited the use of corporate funds for political advertisements that aired within 60 days of an election. WRL sued the Federal Election Commission, claiming BCRA was unconstitutional.  The Supreme Court agreed, finding that provision of BCRA a violation of the First Amendment as applied to advertisements that do not endorse or oppose a particular candidate.  Thus, “issue advertisements” may be aired within 60 days of an election.

Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, 558 U.S. __ (2010)

In this recent case, the non-profit organization Citizens United challenged the BCRA provision that prohibits corporations from making “electioneering communications” within 30 days of a primary election.  Citizens United produced a 90-minute film entitled “Hillary: the Movie,” a documentary that was highly critical of then-presidential candidate Hillary Clinton.  The group received money directly from corporations to make the film and thus violated Section 203 of BCRA, which prohibits the use of corporate treasury funds to release candidate-specific communications close to an election.  Citizens United challenged the constitutionality of this provision, contending that the limits on corporate support violated the First Amendment.

The Court agreed with Citizens United, holding that Section 203 placed an unconstitutional restriction on corporations’ right to free speech.  While the Court upheld federal laws prohibiting corporate contributions made directly to candidates’ election campaigns, it held that corporate funding used to produce speech – including films, commercials, books, and other printed material – is a protected form of political speech. The Court’s decision has been criticized, and proposals have been made in Congress to respond to this decision. 

lexapro viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland what is finasteride used for cialis voucher order viagra sex viagra for women finasteride permanent side effects lexapro vs celexa ciprofloxacin 500 mg for urinary tract infection lexapro side effects men azithromycin 500 mg viagra sex cialis coupons from manufacturer side effects of cialis azithromycin 250mg tablets 6 pack is lexapro a controlled substance when will cialis go generic levitra 20 mg von bayer 200 cialis coupon ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics pfizer viagra coupons from pfizer is tamoxifen chemotherapy finasteride what is ciprofloxacin used for lexapro 10 mg acyclovir 800 mg azithromycin 250mg finasteride reviews ciprofloxacin 500 mg levitra 20 mg precio farmacia natural viagra propecia tamoxifen side effects cialis cost side effects of lexapro 10 mg cheap cialis lexapro side effects in men lexapro and weight gain side effects of ciprofloxacin azithromycin uses generic cialis vardenafil vs viagra azithromycin vs erythromycin escitalopram side effects cialis generic tadalafil cyalis what is ciprofloxacin prescribed for lexapro dosage cialis from canada what does azithromycin treat cialis samples what is lexapro what does finasteride do what is acyclovir used for viagra for women what is escitalopram ciprofloxacin 500 generic cialis at walmart tamoxifen citrate cipro 500 cipro uses does lexapro cause weight gain zithromax z-pak side effects of lexapro in women how does viagra work cialis canada revatio vs viagra viagra sans ordonnance ciprofloxacin uses finasteride 1mg wellbutrin and lexapro tamoxifen interaction cialis coupons printable buy viagra online lexapro and wellbutrin combination therapy viagra vs cialis cialis coupons 2017 canadian viagra finasteride hair loss viagra tesco generic viagra cialis prices viagra vs cialis viagra canada finasteride side effects in men viagra on line no prec cialis daily cialis alternative acyclovir medication tamoxifen langzeitfolgen viagra pills side effects of lexapro generic for lexapro wholesale cialis azithromycin liquid equipe argentine viagra finasteride efectos secundarios finasteride 5 mg cipro viagra soft viagra pillen kruidvat what is cialis cialis generic levitra generic viagra activate tamoxifen therapy what is azithromycin used for cialis generic availability vardenafil 20mg what is finasteride levitra coupon is azithromycin penicillin zithromax dosage viagra bestellen how to use viagra acyclovir cream buy levitra online lexapro weight gain acyclovir ointment 5 acyclovir for cold sores what is acyclovir for canada viagra finasteride 5mg side effects mayo clinic what is cipro usually prescribed for ciprofloxacin 250mg cialis discount effects of stopping finasteride lexapro and weight loss cialis 10 mg buy generic viagra ciprofloxacin ophthalmic solution cheap viagra ciprofloxacin hydrochloride ophthalmic generic viagra 100mg antibiotic ciprofloxacin tamoxifen viagra en ligne livraison 24h zovirax pills lexapro for anxiety levitra dosage cialis pricing lowest cialis prices sophia viagra finasteride tablets is ciprofloxacin a penicillin lexapro overdose what is ciprofloxacin finasteride medication viagra ohne rezept auf rechnung cialis 20mg directions escitalopram cialis patent expiration 2017 lexapro generic name cialis for men viagra nebenwirkungen ciprofloxacin dose azithromycin pregnancy acyclovir ointment price cialis cost of cialis azithromycin three times a week lexapro manufacturer website viagra 100mg ciprofloxacin class levitra vs viagra lexapro vs zoloft cialis dosage recommendations canada cialis levitra without a doctor prescription ciprofloxacin used for viagra alternative zithromax what is cipro used for what is tamoxifen used for acyclovir 800mg cheap levitra viagra substitute tamoxifen and weight gain viagra uk azithromycine eg 500 mg bijsluiter azithromycin 5 day dose pack tamoxifen cost daily cialis cialis 20 mg levitra prezzo in farmacia lexapro dosing azithromycin class acyclovir dosage buy generic levitra cialis otc lexapro coupons azithromycin 250 mg treatment ciprofloxacin spc how to get off lexapro cost of viagra viagra effects azithromycin tablet viagra generic liquid cialis generic lexapro effects of stopping lexapro suddenly cialis free trial finasteride dosage cipro for uti escitalopram nebenwirkungen discount viagra azithromycin without a doctor’s prescription generic levitra vardenafil 20mg acyclovir 800 mg for shingles finasteride 5 mg tab viagra vs cialis vs levitra azithromycin pregnancy category acyclovir 400mg viagra 100 mg cialis pharmacy prices cipro dangers cialis tamoxifen bijwerkingen cialis 5mg viagra 100mg tablets retail price zovirax dosage ciprofloxacin nebenwirkungen levitra online what is lexapro for ciprofloxacin dosierung cialis patent expiration finasteride 5mg tab finasteride vs dutasteride what is lexapro used for cialis website how long does viagra last pfizer viagra cialis coupon print cialis testimonials azithromycin z pak cialis dosage viagra prices side effects of acyclovir buy cialis online how much does cialis cost levitra 20mg finasteride for women viagra price viagra 100 levitra rezeptfrei deutschland cialis on line ciprofloxacin 500mg lexapro side effects viagra generico acyclovir side effects side effects of azithromycin 250 mg what is viagra cipro antibiotic ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics side effects lexapro 5mg cialis coupons cipro side effects in elderly cialis tadalafil ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab cipro drug class what is azithromycin lexapro 10mg side effects of azithromycin viagra tablets cialis 20mg azithromycin coverage ciprofloxacin bnf cipro and tendonitis ciprofloxacin drug class lexapro generic azithromycin for strep throat viagra medicine viagra cialis online viagra cialis side effects finasteride and enlarged prostate ciprofloxacin side effects ciprofloxacin hydrochloride levitra ciprofloxacin dosage viagra wiki how long for azithromycin to take effect cialis coupon 20 mg acyclovir dose zithromax 500 mg ciprofloxacin eye drops viagra for men cialis for sale levitra vs viagra viagra dosage lexapro para que sirve viagra pill cialis 30 day sample zovirax cream lexapro medication viagra coupon what does viagra do azithromycin tablets what is azithromycin for azithromycin and alcohol cialis for women side effects of finasteride 5mg discount cialis viagra alternatives buy levitra cialas viagra kaufen lexapro reviews cialis coupon viagra vs cialis vs levitra levitra prices ciprofloxacin coverage escitalopram 10mg acyclovir for shingles thuoc azithromycin finasteride 5mg women viagra viagra cialis 30 day trial coupon how does cialis work generic levitra post finasteride syndrome where to buy viagra ciprofloxacin hcl cilias finasteride long term effects female viagra how long for lexapro to work viagra for sale uk lexapro withdrawal symptoms tamoxifen and bone pain canadian cialis what works better than viagra viagra tablet cialis canadian pharmacy cipro dosage acyclovir vs valacyclovir zithromax antibiotic acyclovir 200mg online cialis cialis patent expiration date extended weaning off lexapro side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg cialis copay card tamoxifen lawsuits cialis sample common side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg azithromycin eye drops what bacteria does ciprofloxacin kill lexapro dosages buy viagra cialis cheap escitalopram 10 mg ciprofloxacin for dogs azithromycin side effects viagra side effects azithromycin dosage azithromycin for uti viagra on line cialis medication erectile dysfunction cialis cialis savings card ciprofloxacin what does ciprofloxacin treat over the counter viagra cialis samples overnight cialis pills for sale cialis for daily use free viagra zoloft vs lexapro acyclovir 800 mg 5 times a day cialis vs viagra how does lexapro work ciprofloxacin side effects in women first few days on lexapro viagra natural what does ciprofloxacin 500mg treat utilisation viagra escitalopram 20 mg viagra receptfritt azithromycin cialis for bph levitra 10 mg prezzo viamedic cialis how to wean off lexapro without withdrawals azithromycin 500 erfahrungen lexapro side effects in women azithromycine 250 mg acyclovir 400 mg viagra samples azithromycin medscape lexapro withdrawal cialis online azithromycin cost celexa vs lexapro viagra wikipedia lexapro and weight gain in women what is cipro free cialis cialis pills tamoxifen nebenwirkungen azithromycin pediatric dosing levitra coupons zovirax for cold sores cialis or viagra viagra costs side effects lexapro tamoxifen side effects in women over 55 ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg side effects is azithromycin cialis reviews side effects of finasteride azithromycin 250 levitra 20mg cost per pill cialis trial ciprofloxacin 500mg tablets ciprofloxacin 250 mg cialis 5 mg cialis price what infections does ciprofloxacin treat withdrawal from lexapro levitra 20 mg cost walmart cialis without a doctor’s prescription azithromycin 500mg escitalopram 10 mg para que sirve finasteride for hair loss tamoxifen and foods to avoid viagra from canada lexapro benefits for women 9 levitra at walmart best price viagra side effects of tamoxifen azithromycin for pneumonia escitalopram effets secondaires viagra coupons cipro side effects viagra cost generic cialis tadalafil azithromycin 500 ciprofloxacin 500 mg tabletten generic for cialis cipro antibiotics lexapro bula what is tamoxifen zovirax ointment ciprofloxacin side effects after age 60 cialis 5mg daily finasteride side effects viagra online propecia side effects viagra 50mg levitra vs viagra for hardness acyclovir what is acyclovir tamoxifen side effects in women azithromycine nolvadex how does acyclovir work acyclovir dosing buy cialis azithromycin drug class cialis professional stopping lexapro finasteride results cealis azithromycin 250 mg lexapro vs wellbutrin ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg ciprofloxacin drops finasteride 5mg side effects cialis effects levitra bayer 20mg meilleur prix viagra without a doctor prescription viagra without a doctor prescription usa how to wean off lexapro acyclovir dosage for cold sores lexapro 20mg side effects of viagra cialis vs viagra levitra 20 mg viagra single packs escitalopram oxalate finasteride effets secondaires buying viagra zovirax viagra for sale how to take cialis herbal viagra levitra erfahrungen cialis dosage strengths